What do I do- two guy friends? Ten points, I promise!?

Definitely do not try things with the second guy if you don't think of him that way, because you WILL end up hurting him. You have to make it clear that you only think of him as a friend. As for the first guy you need to make it clear to him how you feel (which it sounds like you've already done). And if he still just wants to be friends then you need to respect that and learn to just be friends. I know that is extremely hard to do but you need to remind yourself that he doesn't feel that way about you and it is pointless to try to change that because you can't. Try to find someone else to fulfill that other part of your life and just appreciate having two great friends.